Defiant Behaviour

Defiant Behaviour

Table of Contents

Defiance is a conclusion, not a behaviour. What anyone actually sees is refusal: the person does not do the thing, says no, walks away, goes quiet, or does the opposite. Calling that defiance adds a motive the behaviour itself does not supply.

The distinction matters because a support plan can act on refusal. It cannot act on defiance.

Why the word gets in the way

Describing someone as defiant puts the explanation inside the person and closes the question. Once the answer is that they are being difficult, there is nothing left to investigate, and nothing left to change except the pressure applied to them.

The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission applies the same reasoning. Its practice guide on functional behaviour assessment states that control and power are not functions of behaviour, and that a diagnosis is not one either. A function has to name something the behaviour produces. “Being defiant” names nothing.

Can’t, or won’t?

This is one of the first distinctions a practitioner draws, and the answer is more often “can’t” than people expect.

A task that looks simple can contain several steps the person has not learned, or one step they cannot do. Getting dressed is six or seven decisions. Starting homework requires finding it, judging how long it will take, and tolerating being bad at it for a while. Someone who cannot manage the second step can look like they are refusing the first.

The pattern of refusal carries information. Refusal with one task and not others tends to point at the task. Refusal with one person and not others tends to point at how that person asks, or at the relationship. Refusal everywhere, with everyone, tends to point at something the person is carrying with them, such as pain, exhaustion or anxiety.

Response time is often read as refusal

A request that gets no response has not necessarily been rejected.

Many people need considerably longer to process an instruction than the two or three seconds adults typically leave before repeating themselves. Repeating it restarts the processing, so someone who needed eight seconds now needs eight more. Three repetitions in, it looks like refusal and feels like confrontation, and nobody involved has done anything unreasonable.

A practitioner observing in the setting will often pick this up quickly, because it is visible in the gap between the request and what happens next.

When the request itself is the trigger

For some people the demand is the problem, regardless of what is being asked.

The National Autistic Society describes demand avoidance as a persistent and marked resistance to demands experienced by some autistic people. It can extend to things the person wants to do, and to essentials like eating and sleeping. The Society also notes that everyone experiences demand avoidance sometimes, and that how it is defined and why it happens remain contested and under-researched.

This is often called pathological demand avoidance, or PDA. In Australia the picture is mixed. The Australian Psychological Society notes that PDA is not a widely accepted diagnosis here and has never appeared in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Meanwhile Australia’s national autism strategy recognises PDA as a profile or subtype of autism.

Where this profile is present, the usual approaches tend to backfire. The PDA Society notes that firm boundaries, routines, rewards and consequences are often unhelpful and can increase anxiety and avoidance. That is a significant finding, because those are precisely the responses most people reach for first, and it is one of the clearer reasons to have an assessment rather than persist with what usually works.

What about oppositional defiant disorder?

ODD is a real diagnosis and some families will have encountered it. Raising Children Network describes it as a childhood behaviour disorder in which children will not do what people ask, think what they are being asked is unreasonable, and get angry and aggressive about being asked.

Two caveats are worth holding onto. It usually begins in the preschool years, almost always before the early teens, and it is not common. And a diagnosis describes a pattern rather than explaining it. Even where ODD is diagnosed, the work is still to find out what the refusal achieves, and what is making the demands hard to absorb.

What the refusal achieves

Refusal generally produces one of a few outcomes: the task stops or is postponed, the person gains time, someone comes to them, or the environment changes.

Postponement is the one that goes unnoticed. A demand dropped during the refusal and reissued twenty minutes later has still been escaped, and the refusal has still worked. Patterns like that are close to invisible without written records kept across several weeks, which is one reason assessment relies on data rather than recollection.

Why compliance is the wrong goal

A plan built around obedience tends to escalate, because the only levers available are pressure and consequence.

It also sits badly with how behaviour support works in Australia. Choice and control are foundational to the NDIS. UNSW’s National Centre of Excellence in Intellectual Disability Health lists lack of choice and control among the factors that contribute to behaviours of concern. Reducing a person’s remaining say in their day in order to secure compliance tends to entrench refusal rather than resolve it.

How refusal is assessed

Where refusal is persistent and affecting health, safety, school, work or home life, the starting point is a functional behaviour assessment.

It establishes what is being asked and by whom, and what the person can and cannot already do. It also looks at what else is loading the day, how long they are given to respond, and what happens after a refusal. From that, the practitioner develops a hypothesis about what the refusal achieves, and the strategies in the plan follow from it.

Under the NDIS, only an NDIS behaviour support practitioner can carry out that assessment and write the resulting plan. Families, teachers and support workers contribute the observations it depends on, which is why their records matter so much, but the strategies are the practitioner’s to set and to adjust as the data comes in.

 

Disclaimer: This article is general information about refusal and defiant behaviour. It is not an assessment of any person, not a diagnosis, and not a substitute for advice from a behaviour support practitioner. If refusal has appeared suddenly, or is affecting eating, sleeping or medical care, see a GP first.

Helping Hands Behaviour Support

Get in touch with our team today!

We're a registered NDIS provider offering behaviour support services across Melbourne.

Helping Hands Behaviour Support
Phone
0406 920 296
Opening hours
Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm
Office (HQ)
Suite 10/240 Plenty Rd, Bundoora VIC 3083