Argumentative Behaviour

Argumentative Behaviour

Table of Contents

Arguing is almost always a way of getting something: more time, a different answer, a say in what happens next, or a way out of a demand that feels unfair or too hard. Most arguing is ordinary. It becomes a concern when it happens so often, or so intensely, that relationships suffer and ordinary days stop working.

Understanding what the arguing achieves is what makes it possible to change.

Arguing is a skill before it is a problem

Disagreeing is part of learning to think. Children and teenagers argue partly because they are still developing emotional, social and problem-solving skills, and partly because temperament makes some people more likely to negotiate or argue than others.

Parenting SA makes a similar point about conflict in families, noting that some conflict is normal and part of how people learn to work out differences. Raising Children Network goes further, describing talking, debating and even arguing as signs that children are trying to work things out.

Adults argue for the same reasons. A person who has very little control over their day, their routine or who supports them may argue because it is the only lever they have.

What the arguing is doing

In behaviour support, the useful question is not how to stop the arguing. It is what the arguing achieves. The same behaviour can serve very different purposes.

Arguing often delays or cancels a demand. If a request is dropped or softened once the argument starts, the arguing worked. It can also bring attention, which matters more when attention is otherwise scarce or mostly negative. Sometimes it produces an item or an activity, and sometimes it is the only way a person has to say that something is too hard, too loud or too fast.

It is tempting to describe the person as wanting control or wanting to win. That does not help. The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission is clear in its guidance on functional behaviour assessment that control and power are not functions, and neither is a diagnosis. A function has to name something the behaviour actually produces, because that is the only thing anyone can change.

When arguing is worth a closer look

A few patterns suggest the arguing has moved beyond ordinary disagreement:

  • It happens most days, and across more than one setting
  • It escalates quickly, or takes a long time to settle
  • It is starting to affect school, work, friendships or family life
  • It appeared suddenly, or has changed sharply in the last few months
  • It happens mostly with particular people, or at particular times of day

That last pair matters. Arguing that clusters around mornings, bedtime, homework or personal care is usually telling you something about those moments rather than about the person.

A sudden change deserves attention for a different reason. Pain, poor sleep, constipation, illness, a medication change or something upsetting that nobody has heard about yet can all make a person far less able to absorb a demand.

Argumentative behaviour and demand avoidance

Some people resist requests far more than you would expect, and not because they are being difficult. The National Autistic Society describes demand avoidance as a persistent and marked resistance to demands, experienced by some autistic people. It can affect essentials like eating and sleeping, as well as going to school or work. It also notes that everyone experiences some demand avoidance, and that how it is defined and why it happens are still contested and under-researched.

You may see this called pathological demand avoidance, or PDA. The Australian Psychological Society notes that PDA is not a widely accepted diagnosis in Australia and has never appeared in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Whatever it is called, the practical point holds. Where a request itself is the trigger, pressure makes things worse and choice makes them better.

What about oppositional defiant disorder?

Oppositional defiant disorder, or ODD, is a diagnosis some people will have come across. Raising Children Network describes it as a childhood behaviour disorder where children will not do what people ask, think what they are being asked is unreasonable, and get angry and aggressive about being asked. A diagnosis requires a pattern of angry and irritable mood alongside argumentative or defiant behaviour that causes real trouble.

Two things are worth knowing. ODD usually begins in the preschool years and almost always before the early teenage years, and it is not common. And a blog post cannot diagnose anyone. If the pattern sounds familiar, that is a conversation for a GP, paediatrician or psychologist.

What tends to help

Most of what helps is about reducing the pressure in the moment and giving the person a way to get the same result without arguing.

Offering a real choice within a non-negotiable task often works better than repeating the instruction. Giving warning before a transition helps when the argument is really about an abrupt change. Dropping the volume and the word count helps, because a long explanation during an argument usually adds fuel. So does deciding in advance which things are genuinely not negotiable, and letting the rest go.

None of that works reliably until you know why the arguing happens. That is what a functional behaviour assessment is for. It gathers data across the settings where the arguing happens, identifies what sets it off and what keeps it going, and produces a hypothesis the plan can be built on.

Where arguing sits alongside other behaviours of concern, the findings feed into a behaviour support plan.

 

Disclaimer: This article is general information about argumentative behaviour. It is not an assessment of any person and not a diagnosis. If the pattern described here sounds familiar, speak with a GP or a behaviour support practitioner.

Helping Hands Behaviour Support

Get in touch with our team today!

We're a registered NDIS provider offering behaviour support services across Melbourne.

Helping Hands Behaviour Support
Phone
0406 920 296
Opening hours
Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm
Office (HQ)
Suite 10/240 Plenty Rd, Bundoora VIC 3083